Can your DNA prove that you are Jewish?

November 11, 2026 • 00:19:11
Can your DNA prove that you are Jewish?
The Jewish Perspective
Can your DNA prove that you are Jewish?

Nov 11 2026 | 00:19:11

/

Show Notes

If someone has zero Jewish DNA, does it mean they are not Jewish? If someone discovers their Jewish ancestry through a DNA test, does that make them Jewish?

In this segment of The Jewish Perspective podcast, we’ll explore these questions and discover what modern science can tell us.

Watch Rabbi Belinsky's Video Blog on Youtube

Chapters

View Full Transcript

Episode Transcript

[00:00:01] Speaker A: DNA and Jewishness. Today you could take a DNA test and your DNA test is going to show that you are this and this percentage of an Ashkenazi Jew. Just as a side note, there is a specific DNA marker called an Ashkenazi Jew. There is no DNA marker for a Sephardic Jew because Sephoric Jews have many different ethnic groups. And a Persian Jew is going to have a very different DNA marker than Syrian Jew. And a Syrian Jew is going to have very different DNA marker than a Tunisian Jew. And a Tunisian Jew is going to have a very different DNA marker than a Bukhari Jew. And a Bukhari Jew is going to have a very different DNA marker than a Yemenite Jew. And we broadly call all of them Sephardic, even though ethnically they are somewhat different. And this is because Ashkenazi Jews lived in one community that lived and moved around together and married into each other, as opposed to, let's say Yemenite Jews lived in their own secluded community and they married only within Yemenite Jews. And so were Bukharian Jews, and so were Syrian Jews. So that's why for Sephardic Jews, there are many different markers. Now, also, we all know that Sephardic and Ashkenazi Jews are not the only groups of Jews that there are. There are, for example, also Italian Jews. Italian Jews have been, unfortunately, most of them have been the largest part of their community has been annihilated during the Holocaust. So we don't have so many of them. But there are Italian Jews. They are neither Sephardic or Schinozic. And also Greek Jews. Greek Jews are not Sephardic or Schnazic. And there have been other denominations of Jews. So what we call in colloquial term Sephardic Jews is usually properly called Edei Mizrah, which means the Eastern communities or Mizrahi. So this is what we usually call colloquially Sephardic Jews. So both of them are colloquial terms. They don't have very strict definitions, if very like. As a side note, we usually in general terms call Yemenite Jews Sephardic Jews. Most of Yemenite Jews will not tell you that they are Sephardic Jews. They will tell you their own denomination. So are they Sephardic? They are not. I don't know. So how Sephardic and Ashkenazic Jews separated from each other, that's a whole other topic, but about DNA specifically. So first of all, can someone's DNA confirm that he is Jewish, or can someone's DNA confirm that he is not? Jewish. And the answer is that just on DNA alone, you cannot come to neither positive nor negative conclusion. For example, first of all, about a negative, if there is a person who converted to Judaism according to the Jewish law, he is 100% Jewish. He is as Jewish as the Chief Rabbi of Israel. His children are as Jewish as the Chief Rabbi of Israel. But if you'll take his DNA test, his DNA test will say that he's 100% Chinese or 100% Russian or 100% Irish. So that's why if someone's DNA test shows absolutely zero, absolutely no, anything Jewish doesn't mean anything yet he could be fully Jewish. It also could work the other way around. If somebody intermarries, a Jew marries non Jewish woman. And this was many, many generations ago. We know that the most famous DNA test is called 23andMe because it go 23 generations ago. What if the guy intermarried 24 generations ago? Then he's not Jewish, his children are Jewish, but the DNA test will never show that. So in other words, we know that the DNA test is not going to be showing that. Now also, they have found specific DNA markers for Kohanim. So one would assume that maybe we can use a DNA marker for a Kohen to determine that he's a Kohen. For example, I come to my synagogue my whole life and I thought that I'm just a regular Jew. I take a blood test and I found out that my blood has coin marker. Now, being a coin is transferred only through the father. So there are DNA markers that only get transferred through the father. So according to that marker, I would assume that maybe I could say that I'm a coin. Well, it doesn't work this way either. Why? Because let's say if there's a coin who he is marrying a non Jew, then his children will not be Jewish, but his son will have a coin marker. And then this son marries a Jew. So now he is having Jewish children. His children are Jewish. But are his children Kohanim? No, his father is not Jewish. A non Jew cannot be a Kohen. So this is why, even though we know that being Jewish is passed strictly through the mother, and we know that there are matrimonial DNA markers that are passed only through the mother's line. And therefore you could track down if somebody's mother is Jewish, but it's still, it's not working 100%. Same thing with the coin. We know that being coined is passed only through the father. But with the case that I described, for example, and there are several other cases. So this is with regards to whether DNA could be used to establish whether somebody is for sure Jewish or for sure not Jewish now. But then there is another question which is a much more practical question. And this has been debated recently and at the highest levels of the Jewish courts, including Chief Rabbinate of the State of Israel and several very prominent rabbis were discussing it for quite a while. These questions arose only a couple of decades ago. And there is a person who has been involved in this decision making is a rabbi who I know very, very well, Rabbi Yorub Oman, who is a Chabad rabbi in Sydney, Australia. He's the head of Australian Jewish Court based in. When I worked in Australia, I was helping him out in his synagogue. We got to know each other really well, even though we first met much earlier. He's from Leningrad also. So this was actually his decision. And this decision was upheld and approved by all the Rabbinic courts, including the Chief Revenant of Israel. We, historically, primarily, we're always determining whether somebody is Jewish or not based on the community and the family tradition. If somebody is a part of a Jewish community and if somebody is an observant Jew and he is a part of an observant Jewish community, and his family has been part of an observant Jewish community for as far as we can remember, we have no reason to suspect that he is not Jewish. The question comes with non observant Jews, non observant Jews, they might not be a part of a Jewish community, or at least to that extent. So how do we know that and what do we do? So this is where we still need to rely on the family traditions and we need to rely on the records, on the documents, and we need to rely on the community around them. And that's why to determine someone's Jewishness, as every rabbi often has to do. And by the way, the same Rabbi Oman who I just mentioned has a service that he provides. It's called JewishStatus.org It's a website that he heads an organization that does research and they dive deeply into documents of every country in the world, including former USSR countries, including Arab countries, including West European countries. They check both government records and cemetery records and birth records and everything else. It's a big organization that he's heading and they do check according to the documents. They also interview the family and they want to know what the family history is. So here is a situation where, let's say an organization like Rabbi Ulman's organization, JewishStatus.org, let's say they are doing their investigation and their investigation is somewhat inconclusive. In other words, there are some strong indications that this person is Jewish, but they still cannot say it with 100% certainty. This is where a DNA test will help. So if in this situation, a person goes and takes a DNA test and his DNA test is going to come back and say that on his maternal lineage line from his mother's side, as far as the DNA test can trace, everybody's Jewish, then. So DNA test could be used as a support for other research that has been already done. Now, you asked about why being Jewish, being transferred from through the mother, why is Jewishness matrilineal? And Kohen or Levi is patrilineal? So this is an important question because in Judaism, everything that has to do with your soul is transferred through the mother. You get your soul. Your Jewish soul came to you through your Jewish mother. Because your Jewish mother, when she had you in her womb for nine months, that's when she gave to you your Jewish soul. The father is not the one who's giving a child his soul, but when it comes to a person's identity, the identity goes through the father. The functional part of your life goes through your father. That's why when, let's say you're being called up to the Torah, you are being called up. Yaakov Gedalia Ben Lab. We don't say your mother's name, we say your father's name. Whenever we recite a prayer for the sick, we what do we say? We ask for God to heal the person. And we say to heal a person's soul and to heal a person's body, you will say, well, why are we asking God to heal a person's soul? His soul seems to be fine. Well, everything physical in this world is a resemblance of what's going on in this person's spiritual reality. So in other words, if person has a physical ailment, it's because something needs to be fixed in his soul. And we are asking God to fix it from up on top, to fix it from down here, to deal with symptoms, to deal with the physical reality that doctors could do. But we are asking God to address the root cause. And root cause is always spiritual. So because we are asking God to address the root cause, that's why whenever we recite a prayer for someone's recovery, we mention his or her mother's name, because it has to do with the soul. If we recite a prayer just for someone to be successful, there's a misha Baruch, for somebody to be successful, or when we call somebody to the Torah, we mention the person's name and his father's name, because it's not something that has to do with the soul, it has to do with his identity. When we are reciting prayer for the sick, it's always the mother's name. And same thing, when we recite Iskir, it is a prayer for the soul. So it's mother's name. But identity and functionality of a person, the functional, the mission of a person, I should say identity, functionality, and the mission of a person comes from the father. That's why tribal affiliation goes through the father. So if, let's say today, we most of the time don't know for which tribe we are anymore. But let's say if a man from tribe of Binyamin would marry a lady from the tribe of Levi, their children would be considered to be from tribe of Binyamin. You'll say, well, but what about the mother who is from the tribe of Levi? Well, Jewish identity goes through the mother. But person's identity, and as far as his mission and as far as his job within the Jewish community is through the father. There's an old Jewish story about a new immigrant coming from shtetl, from a small town in Russian Empire here to the US he doesn't know anybody. He doesn't know anything. People look at him as a newcomer who is not worth anyone's attention. He's thinking, how can I get some attention, some respect? Maybe somebody's going to talk to me. So he figures that he'll go to Eshu. He'll go to synagogue, and at the first time when he'll come there, he'll tell them he's a Cohen. So Cohen gets a special place. Cohen gets called to the Torah first. Cohen gets special privileges in the synagogue. He recites blessing on Yomtif. So he decides that, oh, I will tell in the synagogue that I'm a Kohen, and this is how I'll get a little bit more of recognition. So he goes to the local synagogue over there, wherever he lands from Russia, and he walks into a synagogue. He introduces himself, says he's a coin. Right away, oh, a coin. We don't have a coin. You'll be our first coin. Wow, they're so excited. And everybody announces, now we have a coin in our congregation. He's so happy and everybody's so happy. Everybody's hugging him and everybody's shaking his hand and everybody's talking to him. His goal is achieved and the first Shabbos, they're calling him up to the Torah first. Ya amot. His name, Berel ben Yankel, Hakohen. And he proudly walks through the entire shul up to the bima, and he is getting to the Torah. And after the Torah, everybody is shaking his hand. And every says, you know, it's a customary tradition in every synagogue, after you get an aliyah, after you've been called to Torah, walk over to the rabbi and shake his hand. So he walks over to the rabbi of the synagogue, who sits all the way in the front, walks over to shake his hand, and he recognizes that this is a rabbi, this rabbi is somebody from shtetl. And in the shtetl in the town in Europe that they are from, this guy was no rabbi whatsoever. As a matter of fact, this rabbi probably can barely read Hebrew. So he comes over and he says, yankel, is this you? What kind of rabbi are you? So Yanka looks him, says, if you can be a Cohen, I can be a rabbi. Whenever a person figures out whether he's a kohen or not, a Levi or not, it all depends on his family tradition, what his family told him, what his father told him. So I'm sure there are a lot of kohanim that have lost their tradition that they are kohen and they are kohanim, but they just don't know about it. And then there are people who I know who, let's say, didn't know that they are a coin, but then they went to a grave site of their grandfather, and on the grave site it says so and so ha, coin. In the Jewish texts and in Jewish graves, if somebody is a coin or a Levi, it usually says so. Or sometimes they put some signs that indicate whenever a coin recites a blessing for a congregation on the holiday, they usually put their hands out, spreading the fingers. So sometimes on the grave of a coin, you have a sign of spread fingers like this, and that is an indication the person is a coin. So today, if you have any Jewish document, a ketubah from someone in a family from the previous generations, or if you have a baby naming certificate or something like that, usually it's going to be written if somebody's a kohen. At tombstones, on people's graves, if somebody's a coin or a Levi, we usually write that. Cemetery records, Jewish cemetery records try to keep this as well. So this is how you can trace back your family if you don't know. But otherwise it's only whether your parents told you that they're Cohen or [00:16:44] Speaker B: not. [00:16:45] Speaker A: And I do know several people who last name is a Levi, but they're not Levi, and whose last name is a Cohen, but they're not Cohen. And then obviously there's many Levian coins whose last names don't indicate anything about Levy or coin. Last names were very often picked arbitrarily. So if somebody was a coin, he would have said, okay, so let my last name be a coin. Also, for example, my brother in law, my sister's husband, his last name is a Cohen. How original. But actually, when his grandfather came from Russia, his last name was completely different. He was, his last name was Kazirog, which was very hard to pronounce in English. And because he was a Kohen, because he knew he was a Kohen, he changed it to Kohen just to be more legible and easier to pronounce. Whenever the Torah is read from scroll during the services, you probably know that in the scroll we don't have anything written besides for the letters which are consonants, there's no vowels. And also there's no melody written there. If you will look in a book of the five books of Moses, in there you have printed letters with vowels, which are dots or lines on top or on the bottom. And also there are signs of melody which are called, or in English, they are usually called, with a fancy word, cantillation. And this is how people know what melody, what intonation to read it with. And in order to read the Torah properly, one has to know both the vowels by heart and the trop, the tune by heart. And people do that preparing. People prepare to in advance before Shabbos to read it. And then when they come here, they already prepared and they know how to read it very often. Tune is the hardest part to read, is the hardest part to memorize. Why? Because reading without the vowels, modern Hebrew most of the time is written without vowels. Also, if you will pick up an Israeli newspaper, it's written without vowels. If you will take any piece of literature in modern Israel, it's written without vowels. So people do know how to read without vowels pretty well. The hardest part is the tune. So that's why very often when somebody doesn't remember the tune so well, just to remind him the tune, he asked for somebody to stand next to him and to show with his hands the specific signs.

Other Episodes

Episode

August 21, 2022 • 00:11:19
Episode Cover

Why is Judaism so petty-minded?

Listen

Episode 5

January 19, 2022 • 00:39:49
Episode Cover

The Kabbalah of Sefirot - class 5

Listen

Episode 0

June 22, 2021 • 00:17:04
Episode Cover

Why does Kind G-d cause suffering?

RabbiV.com

Listen